The Charge of Democracy

By Cassie McClure

May 12, 2024 5 min read

As I was being charged by name with genocide and cowardice by the protesters yelling in council chambers, I thought about my great-grandfather. His crime had been speaking out and warning about cowardice.

The Nazi officers had wanted to kill someone in front of him. He told the officer with the gun not to be a coward, that if the officer wanted to shoot the man, to at least shoot him in the front and not in the back like a coward. Later that evening, the knock on the door came, and they took my great-grandfather away, and my 10-year-old grandmother never saw her father again.

There are a few things I take away from that story: the power of your voice, the consequences of speaking up, the nature of mundane evil, and intergenerational trauma.

I saw a display of that trauma as the resolution on our City Council agenda, calling for a ceasefire in Palestine, became public. Over 100 emails and several phone calls were sent in about five days. One would think that a call for peace would be easy, but it was not.

As the resolution was written by a student-led, pro-Palestine group, the Jewish community in our town felt fear. Some email writers couldn't see beyond their anger and fear; some tried to be constructive, their hearts seeing the pain of others thousands of miles away because when it comes down to it, we're all human.

Many emails to me also speculated what this had to do with our town. I could rattle off that the money used for bombs could be used for bike paths, but that would go unseen. As a local governing body, we felt a need to respond to both the 300 who signed the petition for ceasefire and those who had deep concerns with the resolution. Both of those are our constituencies.

The mayor moved to remove the resolution from the agenda, which is allowed for any item on an agenda as long as there are enough votes to support the removal. It passed, 5-2.

Rage erupted. The protesters got up to yell at the back of the chambers; those who had been sitting in chairs got up to turn around and yell back. The mayor tried to restore order.

Would it have been productive to make almost line-by-line amendments to a resolution that might have inched us toward an agreement that, at its best, would be: We do not condone the killing of innocent people?

But we can't even agree on who those are.

What is happening between Israel and Palestine isn't coming out of a vacuum, with constant conflict that I'm honestly not well-informed enough to detail. Advocates for either side are filled with emotion — informed by religion, informed by generational trauma, informed by immediacy and vividness to death that we've rarely had access to in previous generations — and emotion can cloud their advocacy. However, their emotions are valid — and the lived experiences of others, especially minorities, should be honored.

So why was I charged with genocide? Because I'm now a turncoat to students that I had met with, agreed with, and even stopped by their university encampment to see how it was going. We sat in a coffee shop a few weeks before, and they gave statements and even gave me a binder of information with handwritten tabs. They had given me hope.

As the whirlwind started last week, I reached out to ask if they had contacted the Jewish community. They did not reply.

Advocacy also does not happen in a vacuum. It is built in community, and the frameworks change depending on who is in the community and their experiences. In that way, I also failed the students. I wasn't prepared enough to guide their advocacy and think through what they might need to do to be effective. I wasn't prepared to edit the resolution with my meager experience in global affairs. I didn't know either that we were preparing to pass this resolution on Holocaust Remembrance Day.

At the council meeting, the pro-Palestine group was escorted out by the police. They continued to yell in the lobby. The police chief got up to talk them into going to the front of the building. The news station cameras rolled. There's no such thing as bad press.

There were still two hours of public comment. Disturbing but unsurprising to me was that both sides were fraught with dangerous rhetoric, including direct threats to city council members. That says much more about our citizens, and likely our country, than anything else.

Cassie McClure is a writer, millennial, and unapologetic fan of the Oxford comma. She can be contacted at cassie@mcclurepublications.com. To find out more about Cassie McClure and read features by other Creators Syndicate writers and cartoonists, visit the Creators Syndicate website at www.creators.com.

Photo credit: Raimond Klavins at Unsplash

Like it? Share it!

  • 0

My So-Called Millennial Life
About Cassie McClure
Read More | RSS | Subscribe

YOU MAY ALSO LIKE...